When is an SBA Guarantee Legally Unenforceable
Book a Consultation CallObtaining commercial financing is one of the most difficult challenges facing small businesses. Many small businesses turn to SBA loan programs to finance their businesses.
Without adequate sources of collateral, the participating SBA lender and the SBA always require a personal guarantee before it agrees to approve a loan to the small business. While SBA lenders, banks, financing companies, or other SBA loan underwriters attempt to collect on a personal guarantee, there are certain circumstances where the SBA personal guarantee agreement may be legally unenforceable.
An SBA personal guarantee is a promise to pay a debt for another –which is usually the small business borrower. The SBA personal guarantor is the person making the promise – who is usually a member or shareholder of the small business borrower seeking the SBA loan. SBA Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs) state that participating SBA lenders are required to obtain the personal guarantees of individuals owning at least 20% of a small business’s interest or shares.
When you sign an SBA personal guarantee on behalf of an eligible small business, you agree to be personally responsible for repaying that SBA debt in the event the small business later becomes insolvent. For example: your small business manufactures and sells widgets, and it needs commercial equipment to do so. You go to an SBA lender and obtain financing for the commercial equipment, and part of the financing agreement contains an SBA personal guarantee. Sometime later, due to unexpected circumstances, your small business customers suddenly no longer need your widgets, and your small business fails as a result. If the SBA lender cannot recover the balance of its loan from the assets of your small business, it will then consider suing you personally for the remaining balance pursuant to the SBA personal guarantee you signed.
In other words, when you sign an SBA personal guarantee in order for your small business to receive a loan, you pledge your personal assets as collateral, including your home, the cash in your personal checking account, your savings and investments, and your future wages, which the SBA lender or SBA can try to seize.
SBA personal guarantees are a critical aspect of many SBA loan transactions, so entrepreneurs and small business owners should familiarize themselves with the potential consequences of signing one. In general, to be enforceable, SBA personal guarantee must meet certain criteria.
An SBA personal guarantee must be in writing and it must be signed by the SBA guarantor in the SBA guarantor’s personal capacity.
While this may be obvious, this cannot be overlooked. To be legally enforceable, the signatory to the SBA personal guarantee agreement must sign in his or her personal capacity and not as the “President” or “CEO” of the small business receiving the loan, which is its own legal entity, separate and apart from the people that run and operate it.
An SBA personal guarantee is not legally enforceable without consideration
In fact, no contract is legally enforceable without consideration. An SBA personal guarantee is a type of contract. A contract is an enforceable promise. The legal enforceability of a contract comes from one party’s giving of “consideration” to the other party. Here, the SBA lender gives an SBA-guaranteed loan (the consideration) in exchange for the SBA personal guarantor’s promise to repay it. In a lawsuit to collect a debt, the SBA lender must prove that it has the right to collect the debt, i.e., that it gave the loan (i.e., the consideration) to the debtor. Sometimes, the parties to an SBA loan transaction cannot produce documents showing a right to collect; this may be attributable, at least in part, to the number of times that SBA loans are resold on the secondary market or assigned to other counterparties.
An SBA personal guarantee may be legally unenforceable if it was obtained under fraudulent circumstances or it violates federal law or public policy.
Under certain circumstances, an SBA personal guarantee may be found to legally unenforceable if, for example, it was required from a business owner’s spouse who was not an owner, shareholder, officer or employee of the small business. Obtaining a spousal guarantee under certain circumstances may violate the Equal Credit Opportunity Act (ECOA) and could render the SBA personal guarantee signed by the spouse void.
Can an SBA personal guarantee be revoked?
An otherwise valid and legally enforceable SBA personal guarantee can be revoked in several different ways. An SBA personal guarantee much like any other contract, can be revoked if both the SBA guarantor and the SBA lender agree (with the SBA’s approval) in writing. Some debts owed by SBA personal guarantors can also be discharged in bankruptcy or declared invalid pursuant to court order through litigation.
Many factors can affect the legal enforceability of SBA personal guarantees. If you have any questions about the legal enforceability of an SBA personal guarantee that you are about to sign or have already signed, consult with one of our experienced SBA debt attorneys who can assess your situation and offer thoughtful and practical guidance to assist in your decision.
Contact us today to set up an appointment to discuss your SBA loan issues and problems.
Millions of Dollars in SBA Debts Resolved via Offer in Compromise and Negotiated Repayment Agreements without our Clients filing for Bankruptcy or Facing Home Foreclosure
Millions of Dollars in Treasury Debts Defended Against via AWG Hearings, Treasury Offset Program Resolution, Cross-servicing Disputes, Private Collection Agency Representation, Compromise Offers and Negotiated Repayment Agreements
Our Attorneys are Authorized by the Agency Practice Act to Represent Federal Debtors Nationwide before the SBA, The SBA Office of Hearings and Appeals, the Treasury Department, and the Bureau of Fiscal Service.
Client’s small business obtained an SBA 7(a) loan for $750,000. She and her husband signed personal guarantees exposing all of their non-exempt income and assets. With just 18 months left on the maturity date and payment on the remaining balance, the Great Recession of 2008 hit, which ultimately caused the business to fail and default on the loan terms. The 7(a) lender accelerated and sent a demand for full payment of the remaining loan balance. The SBA lender’s note allowed for a default interest rate of about 7% per year. In response to the lender's aggressive collection action, Client's husband filed for Chapter 7 bankruptcy in an attempt to protect against their personal assets. However, his bankruptcy discharge did not relieve the Client's personal guarantee liability for the SBA debt. The SBA lender opted to pursue the SBA 7(a) Guaranty and subsequently assigned the loan and the right to enforce collection against the Client to the SBA. The Client then received the SBA Official 60-Day Notice. After conducting a Case Evaluation with her, she then hired the Firm to respond and negotiate on her behalf with just 34 days left before the impending referral to Treasury. The Client wanted to dispute the SBA’s alleged debt balance as stated in the 60-Day Notice by claiming the 7(a) lender failed to liquidate business collateral in a commercially reasonable manner - which if done properly - proceeds would have paid back the entire debt balance. However, due to time constraints, waivers contained in the SBA loan instruments, including the fact the Client was not able to inspect the SBA's records for investigation purposes before the remaining deadline, Client agreed to submit a Structured Workout for the alleged balance in response to the Official 60-Day Notice as she was not eligible for an Offer in Compromise (OIC) because of equity in non-exempt income and assets. After back and forth negotiations, the SBA Loan Specialist approved the Workout proposal, reducing the Client's purported liability by nearly $142,142.27 in accrued interest, and statutory collection fees. Without the Firm's intervention and subsequent approval of the Workout proposal, the Client's debt amount (with accrued interest, Treasury's statutory collection fee and Treasury's interest based on the Current Value of Funds Rate (CVFR) would have been nearly $291,030.
Clients personally guaranteed an SBA 504 loan balance of $337,000. The Third Party Lender had obtained a Judgment against the clients. We represented clients before the SBA and negotiated an SBA OIC that was accepted for $30,000.
Client personally guaranteed SBA 7(a) loan for $350,000. The small business failed but because of the personal guarantee liability, the client continued to pay the monthly principal & interest out-of-pocket draining his savings. The client hired a local attorney but quickly realized that he was not familiar with SBA-backed loans or their standard operating procedures. Our firm was subsequently hired after the client received the SBA's official 60-day notice. After back-and-forth negotiations, we were able to convince the SBA to reinstate the loan, retract the acceleration of the outstanding balance, modify the original terms, and approve a structured workout reducing the interest rate from 7.75% to 0% and extending the maturity date for a longer period to make the monthly payments affordable. In conclusion, not only we were able to help the client avoid litigation and bankruptcy, but our SBA lawyers also saved him approximately $227,945 over the term of the workout.